大象传媒

Psychosis is central to a western idea of criminal聽insanity. There exists, however, disagreement and controversy on how criminal insanity relates to mental disorders, as was demonstrated in the 22 July case in Norway.

Professor Linda Gr枚ning at The Faculty of Law, University of Bergen (UiB) will receive 12 million NOK from 聽over a 5-year period to study the legal understanding of psychosis and how it relates to criminal insanity.

鈥淭he project will focus on how the law understands mental illness and especially the relation between psychosis and criminal insanity. Our aim is to develop a more nuanced legal understanding of mental illness,鈥� Gr枚ning explains.聽

Legal ambiguity

In legal terms, criminal capacity and sanity refers to the ability to take responsibility for one's actions and is fundamental for decisions about punishment. Most countries have rules that exempt children, as well as serious mentally ill and intellectually disabled offenders from criminal responsibility.

鈥淧sychosis is central to the law鈥檚 decisions about who should be held criminally responsible and punished, and who should not, in all countries. At the same time, the law is unclear about why and how psychosis is relevant for criminal responsibility,鈥� Gr枚ning points out.

鈥淭his lack of clarity has in practice led to an association between criminal insanity and psychiatric diagnosis, and聽many of those acquitted due to insanity are diagnosed with schizophrenia.聽This connection between insanity and diagnostic categories is problematic and may be stigmatizing to persons with mental illnesses,鈥� says Gr枚ning.

Collaboration with philosophers and mental health researchers

To expand the legal understanding of criminal insanity and psychosis, Gr枚ning is collaborating with world-leading philosophers and researchers in psychiatry and psychology.聽

鈥淥ur collaboration will emphasize recent mental health research on psychosis, that approaches this phenomenon as dimensional, and beyond the constraints of diagnostic categories,鈥� Gr枚ning says.

The researchers in the project are planning interdisciplinary publications, seminars and workshops. They will also invite representatives from prosecuting authorities, lawyers, legislators, and other relevant persons to share their experiences in the field.聽

A focus on the Norwegian model

To develop a legal framework for understanding criminal insanity and psychosis, the researchers will also relate their work to existing models for insanity currently used around the world today.聽

鈥淎n important dimension of the project is to explore the Norwegian legal model. Little research has been done on the Norwegian model internationally. Our exploration of insanity and psychosis within the legal framework of this model may provide a valuable contribution to the global discussion,鈥� says Gr枚ning.聽

鈥淗opefully, the project will develop needed legal knowledge and help to reduce the stigma associated with mental illness and crime,鈥� Linda Gr枚ning says.